Thursday, September 29, 2005

Study: Religion Bad.

According to the study, belief in and worship of God are not only unnecessary for a healthy society but may actually contribute to social problems.

Apparently they is serious. According to this "study", nations/societies which are more "religious" have a higher incidence of "dysfunction".

You know what drives me NUTZO about this kind of news story? It's not just that I disagree with the results. It's something that happens a lot with "studies" on everything from the latest food linked with a certain disease to the factors associated with teen drinking or whatever.

PEOPLE. THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CORELLATION AND CAUSATION!!!!!

I can't stress this enough. But the media, in its sensationalism, and the idealogue with an agenda will fuzzy-up the distinction to suit their purposes. Here's a typical example from the above article:

He [the author of the study]said that the evidence accumulated by a number of different studies suggested that religion might actually contribute to social ills.

One might argue that societal problems possibly cause more people to turn to religon. Or one might argue that there are a multitude of factors invovled here - from which "dysfunctions" are counted, their relative weight, the cultural, economic, and historical factors (how does a study "control" for all these?).

Add to that the question of what "religious" means - which religion are we talking about? Christianity, in all its forms? Islam? I wonder if this study would say Islamic countries are "dysfunctional" or not.

Does anyone else here smell an AGENDA???? The whole thing is laughable - that something like this could even be scientifically knowable. Give me a break.

EDIT:

WELL WELL, LOOKIE Here....
It appears the author of the study is a member of the Council for Secular Humanism. His bio:

Gregory S. Paul
A respected expert on Dinosaur anatomy, paleontology, and geology, Gregory Paul is an excellent candidate to counter young-earth creationists. His book, Beyond Humanity, discusses the impact of intelligent cybertechnology on religion, further equipping him to speak on the role of religion in society. Because of his scientific background, Paul is also able to speak on broad debate issues, such as evolution v. creationism and the like. Paul has written two articles for Free Inquiry: "The Secular Revolutionof the West" (Summer 2002) and "The Great Scandal: Christianity in the Rise of the Nazis" (Oct-Nov 2003, Dec 03-Jan 04).

9 comments:

Bunnie Diehl said...

Amen! I actually went to the journal and read the study. The author performed the least complex regression analysis I've ever seen. He controlled for nothing. Not income, not heterogeneity, not level of prenatal care, nothing. I would have failed any of my econometrics classes if I'd done such a crappy analysis.

The Cubicle Reverend said...

I saw this too. How pathetic. I guess it is a bad thing to teach people to love their fellow man and serve selflessly.

MikeGene said...

I have some fun with this study:

http://telicthoughts.com/?p=297

Sean Gleeson said...

I went and did my own study, using the methods pioneered by Gregory Paul.

Preachrboy said...

Holy smokes, Mike and Gene. I thought -I- had too much time on my hands! Funny stuff though. Thanks for stopping by.

Eric C. said...

Umm, sorry to tell you all, but the governing body of the ACLU got together and voted: correlation now does indeed equal causation. (Except, of course, in matters of gun violence!)

Editor Choice said...

Quality blog, enjoyed it. I will comeback.
I wanted just to mention an interesting site about Religions. With more than 500 pages, Religion News and Articles: Religion Universe: Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, Taoism (Daoism) and many others

wpb-38F48A said...

Great blog you have! I really enjoyed it. I heard of a great site that is giving away a free set of Nike Golf Clubs. I think your readers will enjoy it. Just click the link below and enter your Zip Code to see if you qualify!
Free Nike Golf Clubs!

Kim said...

Hi there, It never ceases to amaze me of the quality of blogs that can be found. Yours is very interesting indeed!

I have a article directories website pertaining to article directories.

Check us out sometimes. :)