It might strike you funny that we practice this very visible ceremony – the imposition of ashes – when we have the words of Jesus warning us, “Beware of practicing your righteousness before other people in order to be seen by them, for then you will have no reward from your Father who is in heaven”
He goes on to unpack that general principle with further commentary on how we pray, how we fast, how we give.
It’s not that praying, fasting, or giving are to be avoided. In fact these are all pious practices that Jesus assumes the Christian will do. These are all helpful Lenten disciplines, but the key is this: do not do them “in order to be seen by other people”.
Jesus is teaching us the danger of show-boating our faith. Warning us against making a display of our righteousness. And it’s a well-taken point.
For everything we do, even as Christians, even the good and helpful and holy practices of the faith – can be a playground for the sinful nature to pervert and profane. Where God builds a cathedral, the devil builds a chapel, Luther said.
And so the temptation for us, even in our pious practice of Christianity, is to take this things which are meant to be helpful and spiritual, and turn them into something else: perhaps just another way of boasting of our own righteousness. Wouldn’t it be nice if other people see how good I am? Maybe even God will recognize how good I am, and reward me! So the twisted sinful thinking goes.
But the penitent season of Lent calls us to do just the opposite. We have nothing to boast about, ourselves. Our best works are as filthy rags. We are dust, and to dust we will return. Let the ashes on our foreheads remind us of this, as a sign of repentance, that we are sullied by sin, stained by its guilt, and deserving of death.
Consider fasting this Lenten season. Many have a practice of “giving something up” for lent, as sort of a fast from a certain food or some other pleasure. We may consider literally fasting, even, for certain hours of the day, or some such discipline.
Consider Jesus, who fasted for 40 days in the wilderness, but even more, did battle with the devil and won! For him, the fast served as a time of testing and proving before he undertook his public preaching, his miracles, and his suffering and death. For us, let the fast of Lent also lean forward toward Holy Week and Christ’s crucifixion and resurrection.
Prayer, another Lenten discipline, really a much wider and deeper part of the Christian life. We call upon God’s name not as an act of show, to be seen, but in humble need, like a poor beggar. We call on him because we need his good gifts. We call upon him because he invites us to do so. And we call upon him in the name of Jesus, whose life and death alone make our prayers acceptable, even pleasing before God.
Likewise our giving, not just a Lenten discipline, and our Lord assumes will do it, but warns us not to do it to be seen.
Lent is a good time to commit to a greater and deeper discipline of prayer, fasting, or giving. A good start might be taking up a family devotion, or committing to our Wednesday evening services.
But back to the ashes – here is something that is less a private practice of self-discipline, or even a personal act of piety – but more a corporate confession of repentance at the beginning of the penitent season. Together, we bear upon our flesh an outward sign of death, that we are dust and to dust we shall return. Thus the wages of sin are shown forth in a very outward way. This isn’t “practicing our righteousness before other people” as much as “confessing our unrighteousness apart from Christ.”
We take our cues from the Joel reading, rending our hearts in repentance, and so many others of the Old Testament, in which things like sackcloth and ashes served as outward signs of contrition and repentance. Like the people of Nineveh, who repented at the preaching of Jonah, and wore sackcloth and sat in ashes from the king on down to the slave, and even the animals!
We mourn our sins and look to Jesus for our only salvation. Let these ashes testify to this. Thus, the ashes are marked upon us in the shape of a cross – a reminder that the sin and death we deserve was imposed upon him, and he bore it unto death for us.
But Jesus doesn’t just warn us and scold us about improper piety. He doesn’t just exhort us to keep our spiritual practices of faith from becoming a show. He also reminds us where true treasure is found.
It’s not on earth. It’s not in the finer things of life. It’s not in the outward, the flashy, the showy, the silver and gold. The true treasure is in heaven.
That is to say, the eternal reward that is not like earthly rewards, which are earned and deserved. His reward is heavenly, and Christ gives it to us for free – the promise of a resurrection and life without end.
You are like your sinful first father Adam. You are dust, and to dust you shall return. Everything you have in this life is perishable, and will also fade and pass away. Nothing in this life, even the best things, will last forever.
But we have something more. We have something that moth and rust cannot destroy, and no thief can steal. We have an imperishable treasure kept secure for us in the mansions of heaven. We have the cross of Christ, the blood of Christ, and the life of Christ.
Therefore repent and believe in him. Practice your piety, but not to be seen by man. And know that your reward is great in heaven. In Jesus Christ our Lord, Amen.