Thursday, March 27, 2025

Sermon - Lent Midweek 3 - Matthew 26:62-63

 


So far our Midweek services have considered especially those individuals who were close to Jesus in the passion account.  First, Judas, who was close enough to dip bread in the same bowl as Jesus, one of the 12 and treasurer of the group, but also the betrayer.  Then there were Peter, James and John, the inner circle of the inner circle, with a front row seat to the Transfiguration, but also to Jesus’ intimate prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane.  Close to Jesus, about a stone’s throw away, but still overcome with sleep. 

Jesus’ prayers and their slumber would be interrupted however when Judas came with the soldiers who arrested Jesus.  And quickly the disciples scattered, and Jesus was bound and taken to the palace of the High Priest to be put on trial.  Here our series picks up tonight, with the High Priest, and his “close questioning” of Jesus.

To be sure, this wasn’t a fair trial.  It wasn’t even legal or legitimate, as the law said trials couldn’t be conducted under cover of darkness.  Also, it seems, the whole Sanhedron (the Jewish Council) wasn’t present, and so in modern terms we might suggest they didn’t even have a quorom. 

Add to that, the evidence was scant, and most had no case.  In fact that the witnesses testified falsely, until they came with the half-truth that Jesus talked about destroying and rebuilding the temple.  The verdict seemed to be assumed before the evidence was heard.  No presumption of innocence here.  The fix was in for Jesus.  His enemies had just been waiting for this opportunity.

It really is one of the great ironies of the Passion account, isn’t it?  That Jesus is put on trial, when it is you and I who should be on trial before him.  Indeed, he is the one who will one day judge the living and the dead, as we say in our creed.  And even more ironic that the High Priest is the one to question Jesus here, as Jesus is the Great High Priest, of a higher order than this Levitical office bearer.  Jesus’ priesthood is of the order of Melchizedek.  Jesus makes the ultimate sacrifice of himself, for the sins of all people.  Christ the victim, Christ the priest.

And that this man, Caiphas, would question Jesus is even deeper irony.  That he would interrogate and demand answers from the one who has all the answers, and who alone has the right to question mankind.  But here we are in the farcical court of Jesus’ trial, the divine irony running thick as molasses.

But Caiaphas isn’t, wasn’t, and wouldn’t be the only one.  Sinful man has a long history of putting God on trial.  Of questioning our creator in great arrogance and pride.  Close questioning of God with doubts and cynicism.  Subjecting his holy word to all manner of tests, just like the Serpent did in the garden, “did God really say?”

And if it’s a courtroom you want to talk about, it’s not God who is really on trial, but you and me.  We stand condemned by the just evidence and the impartial judge.  Our record is clear – we have broken God’s commandments and deserve the death sentence.  We are put to the test by the law’s accusations, and found wanting.  We stand guilty as charged.

That old Caiaphas had no problem close questioning Jesus, getting right up in his face.  And the devil himself does the same to us.  Satan means “accuser” after all, and he excels at it.  The devil loves to question us, question our faith, God’s word, and to get us to do the same.  He sows doubt and fear and confusion wherever he goes, and would plant those in your very heart.  He gleeful throws your sin in your face and tells you even God can’t forgive something so foul.  Or else he lies and tells you your sin isn’t that bad, isn’t really sin, or doesn’t really matter.  Anything but the truth, anything but repentance and faith.  Anything but a sure confidence in the steady and unchanging truth of God’s word.

But there stands Jesus before Caiaphas, on trial for sins he didn’t commit.  Faced with accusations that don’t belong to him.  It’s a travesty of justice, but in a divine mystery beyond comprehension, it is the very plan of God from eternity.  That this man, this Son of God, would bear the guilt and punishment that by rights belong to us.  He takes our place under the verdict of death.  He becomes the one to bear all of it, for the sake of us all.  The innocent for the guilty, the righteous for the unrighteous, the divinely provided scapegoat for the sins of all people.

The truth did come out at this trial, however, as Caiaphas questioned Jesus closely.  After all the accusations and all the false testimony, after all the attempts to get Jesus to break, to give them something to use against him, finally the high priest spoke up, putting the question to Jesus – the only one that really mattered:

And the high priest stood up and said, “Have you no answer to make? What is it that these men testify against you?”[i] 63 But Jesus remained silent. And the high priest said to him, “I adjure you by the living God, tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God.” 64 Jesus said to him, “You have said so. But I tell you, from now on you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power and coming on the clouds of heaven.” 65 Then the high priest tore his robes and said, “He has uttered blasphemy. What further witnesses do we need? You have now heard his blasphemy. 66 What is your judgment?” They answered, “He deserves death.”

Are you the Christ?  If he claimed that falsely, it was blasphemy, and deserved death.  But Jesus is the Christ, and the Great High Priest, and the Son of God all rolled up into one.

His priesthood is not one of accusation, but of absolving us of sins.  He comes not to put us on trial, but to free us from the guilty verdict. 

He would answer Caiaphas truthfully, for he would not divert from his cross or turn away from bitter death.  He would embrace the penalty.  All for you, dear Christian.  In Christ, you are “not guilty.”, before God, forever.

One day, we, along with Caiphas, and all people, will see the Son of Man coming on the clouds of heaven.  And then he will judge the living and the dead.

But there is no terror in that day for those who are not guilty, whose sin is paid for, who stand in the righteousness of Christ.  There and then, we receive the completion of the good work begun in us.  There, we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is.  There we will no longer weep or suffer any evil thing, for Christ our Lord has saved us, and we are ever safe and sure with him.

No comments: